It is always interesting to study how the social and physical needs of our daily lives are met in buildings. While researching On Adam’s House in Paradise by Joseph Rywert, I found different opinions on how the role of fire shaped the primitive hut. The concept of a primitive hut has been linked to growth in technology and the formation of community through communication. Traditionally, primitive people were thought to be ones who salvaged and lived in the wilderness. Fire would have been the most advanced piece of technology that the primitive people would use. Hence, huts would be designed around the use of fire.
Around 15 BC, Vitruvius was the first to describe the primitive hut in detail in “The Origin of the Dwelling House” in Book Two of the Ten Books of Architecture. In his account, he describes the origin of both architecture and communication using information based on circumstantial evidence. He noted that “men of old were born like the wild beasts, in woods, caves, and groves, and lived on savage fare”. According to Vitruvius, the first primitive person lived in the wilderness until fire was discovered when trees rubbed their branches against each other and people because terrified when they caught fire. After the flames died down, the primitive people became comfortable around it and drew near it for warmth. A community was formed as people tended the fire together and gathered more people around. Eventually the house was formed through communication and the desire to protect the fire. Vitruvius describes the fire as the first act of communication and spatial expression.
During the Renaissance, the primitive hut was seen more as a shelter for people rather than for the fire. Alberti argued that the primitive hut was initially intended to be a roof to shelter from the sun and rain. As a result, loadbearing walls were built to support to roof. Then windows and doors were built to allow entry and social gathering; let in sunlight and breezes; and let out moisture and vapour. The house was built as a response to sheltering human needs, as opposed to the fire.
In 1735, Abbe Laugier published Essai sur l’Architecture and proposed that the primitive hut was not only the origin, but also the personification of all that was right in architecture. He depicted the primitive man as one with nature. The primitive man salvaged fresh water from the stream, food from the fields and trees to provide his shelter. His house was formed directly from nature, without using clay or stone, and was an extension of forested glade. The hut was built from “column-like tree trunks” with branches for a roof.
Towards the end of the 18th century, Jean-Nicolas-Louis Durand argued that the primitive hut was used to escape nature. Contrary to Laugier, Durand believed that the primitive man sought shelter under trees and in caves to escape weather conditions.
In 1923, Le Corbusier published Towards a new Architecture and represented his version of the primitive hut as a sanctuary turned into a dwelling. He describes the primitive man as one who was riding in the woods on a chariot and stopped to set up a tent to rest.
In 1986, Nell Denari applied the ideas of a primitive hut into a design. He was invited to design a structure for public housing based on Corbusier’s primitive hut and Rywert’s work. The project, named Adam’s House (in Paradise); New York City No. 8407, would be placed on a hypothetical garden between Stanton and Rivington Streets and facing Eldridge Street in the South East side of New York. Its purpose was to “provide a maximum number of low-cost housing units while preserving” the park. Similar to Corbusier’s idea of a sanctuary, Denari also proposed that Adam’s House should be a monastery in the city, a place of home and sanctuary. The house combined features from New York apartment buildings and modernist residences. Its structure was perched on pilotis and it had a roofscape garden dedicated to “witnessing nature’s productivity”.
---
Bibliography:
Ostwald, Michael, and John Moore. Architecture Australia, "Adam's House in Cyberia." Last modified 2011. Accessed November 12, 2011. http://www.architecturemedia.com/aa/aaissue.php?issueid=199703&article=13&typeon=3.
---
12/09/11
Posted by:Joanne Yau